Case dismissed against three men charged over death of homeless manA case against three men over the manslaughter of a homeless Coventry man has been thrown out by a judge.
Judge Mark Wall QC ruled there was “no case to answer” over the death of Adam Chandler.
The 51-year-old, who was previously known as Adam Holmes, was found injured in Hales Street in Coventry city centre at around 10.50am on June 13, 2016.
Police had been called to reports of an incident which started with the theft of a bicycle. Mr Chandler later died in hospital.
Three men were initially arrested on suspicion of murder in connection with the incident.
Alex Cooke, 28, from Harnall Lane West, and Sean Ennis, 29, from Walsgrave Road were subsequently charged with manslaughter and 36-year-old Rocky Murray, from St Michael’s Road, Stoke, admitted manslaughter.
The trial of Mr Cooke and Mr Ennis began at Birmingham Crown Court but was halted following submissions made by Mr Ennis’ barrister Timothy Raggatt QC and Mr Cooke's barrister Michelle Heeley QC.
The submissions related to evidence by a forensic pathologist and uncertainty as to the precise cause of Mr Chandler’s death.
In his ruling on ‘submission of no case’ Judge Wall said: “The prosecution case is that the deceased, Adam Chandler, stole a bike belonging to Mr Cooke from outside a McDonald’s restaurant in Coventry.
“Mr Ennis, who also had a bike with him, gave chase on his cycle.
“Mr Cooke and a third man by the name of Rocky Murray pursued him on foot. The chase was over a distance of approximately 1,000m.
“It was Mr Ennis on his bike who originally caught up with the deceased.
“He pushed or threw the deceased from his bike causing him to end up on the ground.
“Mr Ennis then began to assault the deceased.
“He was soon joined by Mr Cooke and Mr Murray who similarly assaulted the man on the ground.
“Both and Mr Cooke accept that they chased after the deceased, asserting that they intended to retrieve the stolen bike.
“Mr Ennis does not dispute that he forced the deceased from his bike on to the ground but Mr Ennis and Mr Cooke both deny using any violence to the deceased thereafter.”
In his judgement Judge Wall went on to refer to evidence given by prosecution witness Dr Nicholas Hunt, a forensic pathologist, who said Mr Chandler had a number of “pre-existing health problems”.
They included hepatitis C, a cirrhotic liver, a slightly enlarged heart, a significantly enlarged spleen and osteoporosis.
In addition, toxicological results revealed the level of alcohol in his bloodstream was twice the legal limit for driving and chemicals present indicated he had taken a number of legal and illegal drugs, including cocaine.
Judge Wall said the above combined “rendered him more susceptible to arrhythmia and heart failure than a member of the community without such conditions”.
As it was all charges against Mr Ennis, Mr Cooke and Mr Murray were dismissed.
