Strictly Come Dancing’s shock exit means its soul is up for grabs
Ellie Goldstein’s dramatic departure from Strictly this week – thanks to a unanimous judges' decision – was, like all great dance moves, all about timing.
It’s not just that Ellie went home, breaking a nation’s collective heart and ensuring no dry eyes in the Strictly studio. It’s not just that Strictly voted off its best storyline – it’s that her exit came just as Tess and Claudia’s departure looms.
The momentary on-screen absence of Tess herself on Saturday felt like an omen. When the camera cut to her spot and found La Voix instead, rising to the challenge like a trouper, quickly improvising an impromptu audition for the vacant presenter’s gig, it felt like a transmission from the future: Strictly mid-transformation, patching itself in real time.
The show has always had transformation as part of its essence – think of the foxtrot flops who become ballroom gods. And the viewers have usually championed representation: Rose Ayling-Ellis, a deaf competitor, won in 2021, as did Chris McCausland, who is blind, in 2024. Paralympian Lauren Steadman made the semi-final in 2018.
It's so reliable a pattern that Ellie was the bookies' favourite in August with odds of 3/1. The public and the critics loved her. Fans flooded social media with praise for her weekly improvements. Emma Bunton sent her a message of support. But Saturday night belonged to Lewis and this season’s first 40 score.
Anton Du Beke described their Couple's Choice tap dance to Radiohead's 'Creep' as “as good as anything we've seen on any series.”
It was a breathtaking performance – as were those of Alex, Karen, Amber, Vicki… indeed, apart from Harry and Karen languishing at the bottom of the leaderboard by quite some way, the remaining contestants are all from the perfect lines and tight turns school of ballroom.
Which is a different kind of Strictly. Highly polished routines from experienced celebs, delivered perfectly week in week out were not a route to victory in the Tess and Claudia years. They tended to lack story and soul. The public preferred to vote for the journey.
But that era is over. Now every result night is becoming a drama about what Britain wants from Strictly: reassurance or reinvention.
Which may make La Voix and Balvinder the unexpected agents of change. Balvinder is the reassurance candidate. She has been in the dance-off so many times this series that her survival routines are better than her main show dances.
The Rhumba to Shakespears Sister proved certain rules still hold – hit it slow and sensual in the dance-off. In old Strictly there’s still the “quiet survivor” archetype. If the show still has true magic, she’ll at least make it to the semi-final.
Drag star La Voix meanwhile, is reinvention personified, proving a genuine contender and a huge audience favourite, not just for the charisma but increasingly for the dancing.
This week they delivered their best dance to date with a Paso Doble that earned a high score of 35 but the sassy taking-over of the mic, coupled with their rule-redefining performance indicates a different direction. Someone must have a book on La Voix as frontrunner for the next series' main host.
Neither have to win to give guidance as to how Strictly will evolve. Both still offer magic, but very of very different kinds. What do we really want on a Saturday night — progress or comfort? The phone lines will open next Saturday.
https://www.digitalspy.com/tv/reality-tv/a69229468/strictly-come-dancing-ellie-exit/